Lawsuits against CNN and Netflix


This is the best week ever!

As you can see the picture on the left are major players involved in lawsuits against Time Warner, Inc., owner of website, and Netflix for their failure to caption online content.

I am so happy that this week, two major lawsuits were filed on Wednesday, June 15th and Thursday, June 16th. This is the best week ever!

To read bit more about the lawsuit against, here.

Lawsuits against Netflix by Don Cullen and NAD, click the highlights to read more about these lawsuits.

For almost three years, I have blogged about Netflix and CNN for their failures to provide captioning online. I started on September 15, 2009 with my Open Letter to Netflix since they were planning to release free online streaming show of The Wizard of Oz and I pleaded them to provide captions.

On October 3, 2009, Netflix did not, and I decided to cancel my subscription.

October 19, 2009, Netflix was able to upload “Through Deaf Eyes” documentary video about Deaf Culture for online streaming but it does not contain captions, even though it was captioned on the DVD. I was so furious about this.

November, 19, 2009, Google announced that they will provide automated caption feature for their YouTube videos. It was an imperfect system, but Google was able to prove that they can do it. Also, Disney made a mistake for removing captions from their rental DVD, “Up” and we brought attention to this.

November 22, 2010, one year later, Netflix made an announcement that they were raising prices for DVDs, and encourages customers to use online feature at its lower cost. Hence, Deaf Tax was applied upon us because we are unable to access online captions. This led to the protest against Netflix and one guy named Don Cullen decided to file a class action lawsuit on March 15, 2011.

Then today, June 16, 2011, National Association of the Deaf partnered with state association and two law firms to file a class action lawsuit against Netflix.

Netflix announced that they are adding captions to their videos, and it was too slow. It is not 100% access at all. I purchased iPad2, and it did not show any captions on this device anyway. Same for the original iPad which did not include YouTube captions too. I even produced an open captioned iReport for CNN about iPad. CNN accepted my video, and they just don’t listen. Oh, the irony!

Meanwhile, Netflix was not the only major online website who did not provide 100% captioning to all of their online content, especially the ones who already have captions on their DVDs. Another major website, owned by Time Warner, Inc., continues not caption their online video content. Their website comes with online videos without transcripts.

I had a long standing history with CNN, and it all started so many years ago when CNN did not provide real-time captioning on televisions especially during the Desert Storm in 1991.

CNN hosted their first captioned online advertisement on their website, by Capgemini on December 7, 2009.

CNN featured a video from which usually provides captions with their online content, but CNN did not incorporate it on their website! Ironically, it was about hearing loss!

I campaigned against CNN that they don’t caption their news, with a slogan, “CNN : Captioned News NOT!” and I demanded them to caption them now it since the law was passed.

To summarize this, it is good to know that people do share with my concerns and I am giving a hat-tip to all of the major players who decided to take the legal route.

When push comes to shove is the best idiom to this story. Many of us pushed, and CNN and Netflix just did not listen. We gotta shove them with lawsuits down on their throats. We are tired to be as second class citizens, and we must fight for equality especially having an access to the information online.

Apple? Have you been listening? AARP? Have you been listening? Disney?

ABC did. They included captions for ABC Family’s “Switched At Birth” videos. Thank you, ABC Family.

Corporations, it is time for you to start listening to us and take action. We do not want to shove lawsuits down on your throats, as we did for and Netflix.

Thank you,

Amy Cohen Efron

Did you like this? Share it!

8 comments on “Lawsuits against CNN and Netflix

I did remembered 11/13/2009, Marlee Matlin, Academy Award winning actress, author, and spokesperson for the National Association of the Deaf (NAD) for accessible broadband services and Internet media, rocked for access on Capitol Hill last week and testified at the Federal Communications Commission (FCC) field hearing on the National Broadband Plan.
Look like Netflix Corporation fell on deaf ears .That was two years ago. Lawsuits is only last resort.

Clarification posted I recently, It was two years ago not last week about Marlee Matlin went to Capitol.

Way to go Amy! I just got Netflix 2 months ago and boy, I was stunned when I saw NO Captioning. I hope Netflix gets the picture. Pun intended.

I greatly appreciate your blogpost about “3 Responses to “Lawsuits against CNN and Netflix”. I strongly believe that filing a lawsuit is the best way to wake them up.

Hope Apple and its own Mr. Jobs will add closed captions to everything in iTunes(movies, tv shows, news & interview clips, songs and all) on all Apple devices as well. They need to know that we paid a lot of $$ for the best devices on the planet. I am sure they are Deaf-friendly….

How sad that the biggest businesses have to be sued to provide access for ALL consumers, especially when they are paying. One doesn’t bite the hand that pays, yet they felt they can provide only token service for full price.

Let’s not be patsies and continue to support such callousness. I refuse to use Netflix or any service that doesn’t caption everything. Period.

May the lawsuits succeed in changing this sad situation!

Good for both Netflix and CNN! This lawsuit action speaks louder than any words. Way to go!

Actually, the captioning for Netflix’s streaming “Switched at Birth” stops at episode 4.

Leave Comment

5 + seven =